People counter

Counter

Sunday, May 23, 2010

Hollyleaf IS Alive

Pg .28 Of Fading Echoes
"If they hadnt hidden the truth, conspiring like vixens,his sister, Hollyleaf, might have never DISAPPEARED behind the mudslide that blocked the tunnels."
*
Okay I think that is proof enough of that matter. But there is more!
*
Pg.84
*
As Jayfeather sniffed his fading scent, another touched his nose. It seemed oddly familiar as it wreathed around him but he couldnt place it. The fur on his shoulders prickled, Stiffening, Jayfeather felt himself being watched. He spun around, tasting the air, ears pricked, frustrated by his blindness. Was a cat observing him from the shadows? No sound. No scent, other than those Tigerheart had left.*** Who'd be watching me at this time of night?
*
*
Okay so now you all tell me what you think. Oh And thanks Stargaze =^.^=

13 comments:

MadiShae said...

Yeah

Bubbles said...

So true!!!! thats what I thought as soon as I read the end of Sunset, is she really dead?

Seastar said...

I dont think she is dead. This is some of the reasons why i dont think she is dead

★Silverstar★ said...

I don't think they would just kill off Hollyleaf so easily. She HAS to be alive!

~~Silverstar

☆Myra/Alyria☆ said...

Yeah, she's too good of a character to kill. Especially because she was so devoted to her clan. As the author Michael Scott once wrote: "The worst kind of enemy is one who believes totally in what he/she is doing."

Stargaze said...

welcome and HOLLYLEAF IS ALIVE! ANYONE WHO SAYS DIFFERENT IS GONNA BE CROWFOOD! *hisses and flexes claws

fox said...

she has to be alive, i don't think Erin would kill her off that easily!

Seastar said...

Exactlyy! Hollyleaf was like awesome :)

Patchcloud said...

I agree that you can't kill off a important character like that she has to be alive.

Icestar said...

Exactlyy!:D

Anonymous said...

Hollyleaf is totally alive! I just know it, the Erins would say she was dead if she really was, not LOST or GONE. But why did they allow her to live? What I believe is that Hollyleaf might come back to the clans for revenge or something 0.o

Sunset said...

This makes a lot of good points, I really doubt the Erins would just kill off a character so easily who was a one of three of the narrators through six books. Honestly, when I was reading her 'death', it seemed really sudden and unexpected and I had trouble believing it was the last book in that arc.
I like to believe that either Hollyleaf is roaming around either the Clan's land or all the area surrounding it (so near where the mountains would be), or in the underground tunnels. It'd be possible for her to be roaming the Clan's land because after a while she'd probably lose her Thunderclan scent and most cats might not notice her scent anymore, and if she's in the underground tunnels she could become the new Rock which would be really interesting. Hollyleaf always had a really interesting personality, she didn't want to be a queen but she wanted to have power like a leader or the power Stone Teller had. They spent six books developing that and I think it's really unlikely they'd just throw such interesting character development away.
As for that one excerpt from Fading Echoes, though, where Jayfeather scents someone, I had actually figured they were referring to Brokenstar since he had just caught Tigerheart roaming around the borders and he couldn't quite place the scent but it was familiar (referring to when he faught Breezepelt and Brokenstar at the Moonpool). But it's possible it was Hollyleaf's scent, I hadn't even considered it when I was reading.
Wow, long comment. XD

Anonymous said...

I don't think that Hollyleaf is dead because of the proof shown above... I think that she is hiding in the tunnels because the book did say that "there were so many tunnels leading off in so directions".... there might be one that didn't many collapse. It also said "One of the tunnels might even lead into the mountains." I think that Hollyleaf is living in the tunnels but also trying to help her brothers by catching some food for thunderclan. BTW: I am sooooo sorry for Squirrelflight and Brambleclaw...... they were perfect for each other.....