People counter

Counter

Friday, September 25, 2009

HINTS/Spoilers FOR THE 4th APPRENTICE

FACTS:
-Hollyleaf is most likely alive
-Hollyleaf HAD powers until Outcast, when she became the non-power of three
-Leafpool is no longer a medicine cat
-Leafpool is still residing in ThunderClan
-Pinestar is NOT Firestar's father
-There is no Dove's Wing--Dovekit connection -***-
-Lionblaze will have a mate
-Heathertail is still in love with Lionblaze
-Breezepelt and Heathertail will NOT be mates
-Poppyfrost will have a mate and kits in the first book.
-Foxpaw's warrior name is Foxleap
-Icepaw's warrior name is Icecloud
-Cinderpelt was in love with Firestar; Cinderheart has a vague crush on him.
-Brightheart will have an apprentice
-Brambleclaw will NOT succeed Firestar as leader of ThunderClan
-Firestar will lose most of his remaining lives
-DOVEKIT is the fourth apprentice
-Ivykit is jealous of her sister, which MAY drive her to insanity/Hollyleaf/Tigerclaw
-Tigerpaw's warrior name is Tigerheart
-Barkface is dead
-OOTS will have FOUR veiwpoints: Jay, Lion, Dove, and Ivy
-Leopardstar will die in book two
-Mistyfoot will become Mistystar
-Reedwhisker is her deputy
-Reedwhisker is Mistystar's son
-Dawn, Flame, and Tigerpaw will play an important part with Tigerstar
-Purdy will stay in ThunderClan
-Brambleclaw and Squirrelflight will not have kits
-The lake will drain because of beavers building a dam upstream
-The scene with Ashfur, Squirrelflight, and the Three was written before Power of Three
-Goldenflower died of old age in her sleep between Sunset and the Sight
-Stormfur and Brook have kits
-Leopardstar was in love with Tigerstar


QUESTIONS:

Minou(Q): The prophecy refers to the three as being "kin of [Firestar's] kin", but Dovekit and Ivykit are technically kin of his kin of his kin. How do you explain this?

VickyHolmes(A): “Kin” means “relative”, not just the closest generation. So your grandparents are your kin, your great-grandparents, your cousin’s children, their grandchildren – if anyone is linked to you by blood, they are your kin. Technically, the prophecy could have just said “your kin”, but that didn’t have the nice ring that “kin of your kin” does!

Sandcloud(Q): Did you always mean to make Hollyleaf um... go out like she did? and thank you for all you did at the Naperville tour!

VickyHolmes(A): I’ll be honest (gasp! Actually, I’m always honest, I just sometimes hide a bit of the truth): in The Sight, Hollyleaf was absolutely and totally one of the Three in the Prophecy. I always wanted to send her into a place where she would end up doing something dreadful, but I thought this would come about because she misused her extraordinary powers. But by Book Three, I just couldn’t think what Hollyleaf’s power was. Jay and Lion had walked straight into their roles from the moment they appeared in my head, but Holly seemed to reject everything I offered her, from foreseeing the future to reading minds (unlike Jay, who senses emotions but can only read memories). Nothing seemed to fit – and I realized, literally overnight, that she was never meant to have a power. She wasn’t one of the Three, and the knowledge of this would help to crush her, along with all the other doom I had lined up for her. I LOVE it when characters find their own destinies like that! And thanks for coming to see me at Naperville. Anderson’s is one my most favourite stores to visit!

Quailfeather(Q): In Sunrise when Leafpool stepped down from being a Medicine Cat, did she step down to a Warriors status, or was she banished?

VickyHolmes(A): You’ll find out in Omen of the Stars Book One! She’s still on the cast list, if that’s any consolation.

Rainfall(Q): Why did you choose to kill Honeyfern?

VickyHolmes(A): You’re not going to be very pleased with me, I’m afraid. I needed a cat to be killed by a snake in order to have a reason to have deathberries in the hollow, so that Hollyleaf could threaten to kill Leafpool with them later on. I worked back from that scenario, thinking, hmmm, what would be an excuse for Leafpool to have deathberries in her stores when she is so strict about not having them in the camp? How else might she use deathberries? How about laying a trap for something that deserved to be killed? Like…a nasty ol’ snake that bit a helpless innocent cat? Leafpool or another cat might come up with the idea of stuffing a mouse with deathberries to lay a deadly bait for the snake. Now, who can I kill with a snake? Hmmmm… Poor Honeyfern. ***.


Phantomwing(Q): While all of us might wonder about Leafpool, Hollyleaf and Squirrelflight, I wonder about this: what will happen to Crowfeather? While he may have SEEMED to be over Leafpool, we all know that this is not the case, and that he only acted like he did to save face at the Gathering. His Clanmates might get distrustful of him again, knowing that he has two living sons in ThunderClan.

VickyHolmes(A): You are SO RIGHT! Crowfeather is heaving with all kinds of conflicting emotions right now, but as always, it’s hard to know what he’s thinking underneath his gruff, unfriendly exterior. Only Leafpool and Feathertail were able to see beyond that to the sensitive, loving chap underneath (I’m pretty sure Nightcloud has no idea of her mate’s true character). The revelations at the end of Power of Three will echo far into Omen of the Stars, and Crowfeather’s adventures definitely aren’t over. So many good stories to come!


Flametail von Karma(Q): Do Dove’s Wing and Dovekit have any correlation? Also, Half Moon has “strong haunches”, and her father bears an eerie resemblance to Cloudstar. Is this just a coincidence? Not to mention that Whispering Breeze “doesn’t mind getting her paws wet”. Is this implying something about RiverClan, perhaps…?

VickyHolmes(A): Well spotted! I **** lots of clues about the future Clans in the community of ancient cats - so yes, some cats resemble cats we meet later on, some have characteristics that will feature in the modern Clans like not minding water. But Dove's Wing and Dovekit are not directly connected.


Firefawn(Q): why did you kill Hollyleaf?

VickyHolmes(A): Did I? Where does it say that?


Scorchtail(Q): Were Jayfeather and Hollyleaf named after their real parents? But how would Firestar know to name Hollyleaf after her mother?

VickyHolmes(A): Leafpool gave Jayfeather his name as a medicine cat, so yes, she chose it because of Crowfeather. I imagine the parents of a new warrior have some say in their new name, so Squirrelflight would have suggested –leaf to Firestar for Hollypaw. Firestar would have seen this as a tribute to Squirrelflight’s beloved sister, little realizing that it was actually a tribute to Hollyleaf’s real mother!



Lakestorm Wright(Q): If Jayfeather went into the tunnels, and came out in Jay's Wing's time, where did Jay's Wing go? I mean, he had to go somewhere when he went into the tunnels, right?

VickyHolmes(A): Oh no, I was hoping no one was going to ask me about this! Cherith asked me exactly the same thing when she was writing Long Shadows, and I gave her a really convincing answer, but the details seem to have got lost in the fog of my mind. I think I meant that Jayfeather actually became Jay’s Wing – not a reincarnation, not a temporary possession of his body – and by making the decision to go back to ThunderClan, Jay’s Wing had to leave his own Ancient Clanmates to follow a path that he had set for them. Does that make sense? Probably not.



Cometstorm(Q): What exactly will Omen of the Stars be about? I know that one of Whitewing's kits is the three, but can't you just give us a little teaser PLEASE??? Like what the "omen" is?

VickyHolmes(A): Dovekit is the "fourth" apprentice, and the true third cat mentioned in the prophecy. As you can imagine, her sister Ivykit is none too pleased about her littermate's special destiny... And that's enough revelations!

Rainripple(Q): Is Dovekit the fourth apprentice?

VickyHolmes(A): Yup!


Cloudy Havoqk(Q): Since Cinderpelt was in love with Firestar, will Cinderheart have a crush on him?

VickyHolmes(A): Tee hee, I hadn't thought of that! I think she just might... Thanks for the idea!


Flametail von Karma(Q): Can you tell us anything about who will become leader after Firestar? We know it won’t be Brambleclaw, and will be unexpected. Will it be a relatively new character? (New meaning from Power of Three onward here.)

VickyHolmes(A): No I cannot tell you anything about who becomes leader after Firestar. Because I am EVIL.

Ice(Q): Is Leapordstar(sp) going to die any time soon, I would love to see a Mistystar.

VickyHolmes(A): Actually, I don't think I'm giving too much away to reveal that Leopardstar has just died in Omen of the Stars Book Two! Mistystar is now the leader of RiverClan!


Cloudy Havoqk(Q): Do you ever write stories out of order? Like the last chapter first? Or do you always start with the first chapter?

VickyHolmes(A): Oh yes. The scene featuring Ashfur, Squirrelflight, Jay, Lion and Holly (and some fire and the cliff) came into my head before I even started thinking about The Sight. So the whole series was working up to that moment! But when it comes to planning an actual book, I make myself begin at the beginning, go right to the end, and stop.

Morningleaf(Q): Does Heathertail still like Lionblaze? Or are her and Breezepelt really in love?

VickyHolmes(A): Poor Heathertail, I suspect part of her heart still belongs to Lionblaze even though she knows it is an Impossible Love (yay, one of my favourite things!). No way are she and Breezepelt in love! Although their relationship is more complicated than "just friends".


Heartwing(Q): Why did you just have Leafpool retire? I love her but I was expecting Holly to kill her.

VickyHolmes(A): How could she stay as a medicine cat, when she has broken the code so dramatically? And LIED about her children? Leafpool has only herself to blame, sigh.


Minou(Q): Will where Brightspirit comes from be explained? Jayfeather didn't recognize them from StarClan.

VickyHolmes(A): Brightspirit came from long, long ago in the history of Clans - it's quite likely that we'll meet her later on in Omen, as we learn more about the formation of the early Clans.

Storme(Q): Was it really just pride that stopped Leopardstar from breaking her agreement with Tigerstar(when he was about to kill the half-Clans), or was there another factor--something she would never admit out loud--like fear?
VickyHolmes(A): Good question! Most definitely, Leopardstar was afraid of Tigerstar - but also in love with him, poor thing.


Wildflower(Q): Why do you think the Clans are seeming to fall apart now, when they have always been so solid before? Much of it seems to be blamed on poor Firestar by the other Clans because of the leaders turning against ThunderClan. Or is all this because of teh prophecy?

VickyHolmes(A): The Clans are falling apart because they are subject to many, many new pressures - not just moving home, but incoming influences like Sol. The Prophecy hasn't caused the trouble, but it anticipated it, hence the promise of three super-powered cats to bring the Clans back to their original strength.


FireWolf787(Q): Who is Mistystar's deputy?

VickyHolmes(A): Reedwhisker, one of the cats that Firestar and Graystripe rescued during a flood. Reedpaw is Misty's Son? Oh gosh, you're right!

Spottedshadow(Q): Will Ivykit be evil?

VickyHolmes(A): She'll be pretty miffed that her sister is getting all the attention, that's for sure!

FrostfootDreamleaf (Q): Are Breezepelt and Heathertail mates?
VickyHolmes(A): Nope.


Minou (Q) (to All, but especially Vicky): In regard to Hollyleaf, do you consider her the evil one? Was she really evil, or just angry and confused? Also, if she isn't the "Evil One", is she alive and going to come back as evil or is she dead and one of the others will become evil? (btw Hollyleaf looks adorable on the cover of Sunrise =D)
VickyHolmes(A): I’ve said before that none of my cats are truly evil – not even Scourge or Tigerstar, although it might take a few books to reveal the parts of their history that sent them in a particular direction. Hint: see Code of the Clans for a big clue about Tigerstar’s crazed hatred of kittypets! As for Hollyleaf, she was definitely angry and confused. She felt that she had been backed into a course of action that, however repulsive to her, was the only way she could save her Clanmates from knowing that the warrior code had been trampled in the dust. Sadly, the more she learned, the more she realized that there was no way to save them from this terrible knowledge. I’m not going to give away anything about what, if anything, lies in Hollyleaf’s future beyond Sunrise…


Lightstreaqk (Q): Vicky: (I wrote you a letter a few weeqks ago ) Hollyleaf was either crushed by the caves when they actually caved in, or while lost in the tunnels, right? Would her spirit wander the tunnels forever, liqke Fallen Leaves, or will it go somewhere else? In the summary for Sunrise, it said someone would be 'lost forever' Is that what it meant?
VickyHolmes(A): Not sure I can reply to this without giving too much away! But yes, “lost forever” referred to Hollyleaf as she appeared to her Clanmates at that time. Hint, hint.

Spottedshadow (Q): To Vicky: I'm a bit confused about the fourth apprentice. If either Ivykit or Dovekit is the fourth apprentice (I have a suspicion as to which kit it is, from the book covers, but I won't say anything), who are the other three? I'd assume they were Lionblaze, Hollyleaf, and Jayfeather, but if Hollyleaf isn't really included anymore... and also, they aren't apprentices anymore. And, is the fourth apprentice the third cat mentioned in the phrophecy? Because if the third cat in the prophecy is the third apprentice, the fourth apprentice could be a problem... maybe even evil. It seems like finding out your sibling was included in a prophecy and you were just normal might be hard to take...
VickyHolmes(A): SPOILER ALERT FOR SUNRISE: Ack, too many numbers in your question! I think it’s generally known now that Dovekit is the cat referred to as The Fourth Apprentice. The other three are Jay, Lion and Holly, because all four have been “apprentices” to the Prophecy. However, Holly was never part of the prophecy, which referred all along to Jay, Lion and Dove. Gasp! So four apprentices, but only ever three cats who were part of the prophecy. And you’re right, learning that your littermate was part of a super-powerful prophecy while you’re not could send any cat down the path of evil…


Brambleflower (Q): How is Breezepelt dealing with the news that his father had a mate from a different Clan and had three kits with her?
VickyHolmes(A): One word: BADLY.

Scarletpetal (Q): What happened between Daisy and Spiderleg? I mean it was REALLY sudden, like just popped up O_o
VickyHolmes(A): Yup, it was kind of a one-night affair, and Spiderleg was pretty aghast when Daisy announced that she was expecting his kits. I wanted to reflect the fact that in real life, cats don’t mate for life, and pairs wouldn’t raise their kits together in a cosy little family. Obviously longer-term relationships work better in the series, but I thought it wouldn’t do any harm to let some realism creep in. Also, I saw great story potential in Spiderleg being a reluctant father - usually a tom is super-proud of his kits and very affectionate toward his mate, but Spiderleg doesn’t want anything to do with parental duties! This leads to the strength of Daisy’s character coming out, as she forces him to confront his responsibilities, while being a great single mom. There’s a cat for all of us!

This was the author chat but i got it off of the live warrior cat chat!!!

95 comments:

Scarheart said...

Just to tell you less than half of that is true. Don't believe it. I have the answers to all her facts wheter they are true or not. Sorry :(

-Scarheart

Goldenstream said...

ok, THAT was a long post. :) it sounds interesting though. i can't WAIT until oots comes out!

- Goldenstream

Flaming Wolf said...

Well if the author said it, it's probably true. I mean, what do fans like us know? I say it's AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

★Silverstar★ said...

I don't think Cinderpelt was in love with Firestar. SHE was the one who told Fireheart that Sandstorm loved him. If she had liked him herself, why would she have said that? Yes, maybe to remind herself that she could never be with him, but that was BEFORE she become Yellowfang's official apprentice, right? Cinderheart is WAY younger than Firestar. I don't think she likes him, or at least should if she does. But one thing is for sure: Cinderpelt may have SORT OF admired Firestar when she was his apprentice, but she did NOT LOVE HIM.

Stormfur and Brook have kits?! Yes!!!

I'm afraid I agree, not all of this can be true. Why would the authors give out SO many spoilers? Seriously? But I guess we will just have to wait and see.

~~Silverstar

Delaney said...

Oh, and Cherith said before that Brambleclaw will suceed Firestar, so I have to agree with Scarheart, you wouldn't really think she'd give away THAT much.

Long live Bramblestar!

Rainstar said...

Cinderpelt was in love with firestar the erins said it them selves. yes this is an author chat yes this is all true!!! BRamblestar!! Bramblestar!! Hollyleaf is Alive!!!

Rainstar said...

you never no she pretty much only gave away the stuff we already really knew she wasnt giving away any of the top sedret stuff!!!

Scarheart said...

Only, like 2 things in your post were in the erin hunter chat. I'm not trying to be rude but about 90% of that is fake and not true.

-Scarheart

Dreamstar said...

YAY! BRAMBLECLAW WILL NOT BECOME LEADER! YAY,YAY,YAY,YAY,YAY,YAY,YAY!

Ya. Obviously Pinestar isn't Firestar's father. His father is Jake, from Bluestar's prophecy. Jake is also Scourges father!

Dreamstar said...

Oh. Also. No. Most of that was in the Erin Hunter Author Chat. I read,like all of the answers and I saw all of the things that Vicky said, and it is all here.

★Silverstar★ said...

I think your misread that Rainstar, it said he WILL NOT become leader. YAY! GOOD RIDDANCE BOSSY TWO-FACED TREACHEROUS FOX DUNG!

And I still think that a lot of that had to be made up. The only HINT Cinderpelt gave of liking him was when Leafpool was about to run off with Crowfeather and they were arguing. When Leafpool asked her what she had to give up, Cinderpelt was silent and thoughtful. I don't think Firestar was on her mind, I think that she was pondering all that she could have done as a warrior.

And I guess this confirms that it was NOT one of the authors that commented on Sorrelpaw's Blog. I knew it! Just some little kid trying to fool us.

~~Silverstar

Delaney said...

LIKE I SAID, THEY DON'T ALWAYS TELL THE TRUTH!! PLUS, I HATE ASHFUR! HE SHOULD GO TO THE DARK FOREST! bRAMBLESTAR DID NOT DO ANYTHING WRONG, AND PLUS THEY WOULDN'T MAKE SOME 'TWO-FACED TREACHEROUS FOX DUNG' PART OF THE PROPHECY, THE THREE STILL APPRECIATE HIM, AND YOUR BASICALLY CALLING FIRESTAR STUPID, SINCE HE DECIDED TO M AKE HIM DEPUTY! THE ERIN'S CAN GIVE OUT FAULSE INFO, YOU KNOW! AND, IF YOU REALLY DON'T LIKE WHAT HAPPENS, THEN YOU AREN'TY BEING FORCED TO READ WARRIORS, AND YOU CAN GO OFF, AND MAKE YOUR OWN STORY! AND BRAMBLESTAR DIDN'T DO ANYTHING WRONG! IT WAS ALL SQURRELFLIGHT'S FAULT! SO DON'T BLAME BRAMBLESTAR ON ANYTHING! AND IF YOU REALLY THINK BADLY ABOUT IT, THEN YOU MUST BE A 'TWO-FACED TREACHEROUS FOX DUNG' !!!!

Rainstar said...

I agree with Delaney and they said themseles not here but somewhere else too that CINDERPELT WAS in love with FIRESTAR!!!

Dreamstar said...

Okay. Bramblecaw did SO much wrong! He visited Tigerstar! made him believe that he should kill Firestar! Bramblecaw is horrible! He bosses cats around and Squirrelflight did NOTHING wrong! She was with Ashfur, and Brambleclaw broke them up!

Squirrelflight was only trying to protect her sister from what clans would call her and Crowfeather! Squirrelflight loved Jay,Lion and Holly as if they were really her own!

She is upset not because of brambleclaw! Bramble should forgive her! If he doesn't, then he is mean and selfish!

I hate Brambleclaw. He will never be leader, I hope. Because then Tigerstar might haunt his dreams again and Brambleclaw will tur evil like Tigerstar and Thistleclaw!

Don't yell at *Silvertar* for TALKING and saying her thoughts!

That's mean! She doesn't like this cat. You don't like Heathertail! I don't see any reason for you not to like her! What did she do!

In my eyes, Lionblaze did it ALL. He believed that she told WindClan about the tunnels, when she didn't. Then he almost killed Crowfeather and her. He is also selfish!

DIE BRAMBLECLAW AND LIONBLAZE AND HOLLYLEAF! DIE! DIE! DIE!

★Silverstar★ said...

Um, yes, I DO think Firestar is stupid. Not just for making Brambleclaw deputy, for being too soft. And you know, Tigerstar was part of a ShadowClan prophecy that Runningnose received. So yeah, bad cats ARE part of prophecies.

And I'm not complaining, what happens happens. I'm not trying to change the course of the story, but Brambleclaw isn't becoming leader anyway, so I'm glad. How is he a 'Bossy two-faced treacherous fox dung?'? I will explain.

Bossy - Bossy to Ashfur and Squirrelflight when he didn't get his way.
Two faced - He was pretending to be a good warrior when he was actually following Tigerstar.
Treacherous - He was THIS CLOSE to killing his Clan leader!
Fox dung - Sums it all up.

And my opinion on Brambleclaw still stands. I have reasons just as you do. If you really think so poorly of me Delaney, that's your problem, not mine.

(And I still think Cinderpelt did not LOVE Firestar, maybe she liked him a LITTLE though)

~~Silverstar

Delaney said...

HE DIDN'T KILLL THE CLAN LEADER, IF YOU DON'T LIKE FIRESTAR, THEN YOU DON'T LIKE WARRIORS, IF THEY DIDN'T KEEP THE THREE'S SECRET IN THE FIRST PLACE, AND HEATHERTAIL WAS NOT W-A-S N-O-T A MAJOR CAHACTER, NOR WAS WHITESTORM, SO IT'S DOESN'T MATTER ON THE OPIOIONS ABOUT THOSE CAHRACETRS, BUT HOLLYLEAF IS OKAY! AND HE DIDN'T KNOW TIGERSTAR WOULD BE THAT BAD! THAT IS. WHY HE QUIT.!!! HE IS A GOOD WARRIO, NOT PRETENDING, OH, AND LIONBLAZE IS AWSOME! SO YOUR SAYINF THAT LIONBLAZE SHOULD DITCH HIS CLAN JUST TO BE WITH HEATHERTAIL? tHEY WEREN'T MEANT TO BE, LIONBLAZE DOESN'T LOVE HER. lOOK WHAT HAPPENED TI LEAFPOOL AND CROWFEATHER, YEAH, THAT'S WHAT i THOUGHT. aND I'M SURE RAGGEDSTAR DIDN'T CARE! NOR DID FIRESTAR! NOR DID STARCLAN, WHEN YELLOWFANG HAD A KIT! THEY WOULDN'T CARE ABOUT IT! NOR DO THEY CARE NOW, THAT THEY NOW, IT ONLY AFFECTS THE ONES INVOLVED! SHE COULD'VE TRUSTED BRAMBLECLAW! HE WOULDN'T HAVE TOLD! HE'S BETTER THEN THAT!AND ASHFUR IS THE ONE WHO TRIED TO KILL SQUIRRELFLIGHT, FIRESTAR, AND THIER LEADER! HE'S SICK! BRAMBLECLAW. NEVER . DID. HE WAS BETTER THAN THAT! AND TIGERSTAR HAS GIVEN UP ON TRYING TO SWAY BRAMBLECLAW, AS YOU NOTICED, THEN HE WENT TO LIONBLAZE AND FAILED. aND YOUR CALLING ME MEAN, WHILE YOUR DOING TO, SO YOUR BASICALLY CALLING YOURSELFS MEAN!


(OH AND WHO CARES CINDERPELT IS DEAD AND CINDERHEART DOESN'T HAVE ANYTHING TOWARDS FIRESTAR!)

★Silverstar★ said...

Great StarClan, Delaney, why are you being this way?! I HAVE AS MUCH A RIGHT TO STATE MY OPINION AS YOU DO! And you don't have to like Firestar to be a warriors fan. I don't HATE him, he just annoys me. You think I'm not a warriors fan? I own (almost) EVERY single book, read them all the time, and run a very large blog Clan with full dedication. And you think I don't like warriors just because a few cats get on my nerves?

Brambleclaw SHOULD have known that his father was a murdering tyrant, yet he still trusted him.

I don't care about all that Heathertail/Breezepelt/Lionblaze stuff. I'm not a big fan of any of them.

Yes, Squirrelflight was at fault too. They both were. Ashfur did wrong to, but this is not concerning him.

Did I ever call you mean? No. I think you are way overreacting though. We disagree, yes, but I don't hate you for loving Brambleclaw so why hate me for hating him. You say potato I say patato. We can have different opinions and still get along without yelling. My comment about Brambleclaw wasn't directed at you, you know.

~~Silverstar

Scarheart said...

If u insult Brambleclaw, I will personaly fly over to where u live and shred you face! By the way not hardly any of that is true. like 90% is wrong. If you want proof just ask me.

-Scarheart

★Silverstar★ said...

Gee, what's wrong with everyone today? If you insulted Sandstorm I wouldn't say something like that to you, even though she is my favorite cat in all the series. I'd disagree, but we all have our own opinions.

Yeah, I hate Brambleclaw, and with good reason. So what? You can like him all you want, but I will keep hating him. He was bossy to Squirrelflight and Ashfur, and thinks much to highly of himself. That's why I hate him, but if you like him it's of no concern to me. You can think whatever you want just as I can.

Let's all take a moment to remind ourselves that these are FICTIONAL characters, not our personal friends, OK?

~~Silverstar

Dreamstar said...

If someone said anything about Jayfeather, I wouldn't be SUPER mad like you are right now Delaney. I would say why I like him and that is that. *Silverstar* was only saying what she thought. Just like I say with my thoughts. And you say with your thoughts.

I hate brambleclaw, Lionblaze and Hollyleaf. Big-whoop. You don't have to start Wolrd War 3 just because someone doesn't like Brambleclaw.

★Silverstar★ said...

My thoughts exactly. People everywhere hate Hollyleaf, who is my 10th favorite, but I'm not freaking out. I stated my opinion, you can choose to agree or disagree. No need to get all upset about it. Dreamstar is right. As you've said before Delaney, relax, chill. ;)

~~Silverstar

Scarheart said...

Sorry, I can't even shred someone's face unless I had a chain saw. Also, I know we all have our opinions, but u don't have 2 call Brambleclaw a piece of foxdung.

-Scarheart

Dreamstar said...

Well he kind of is...

Brambleclaw-Bossy Piece of Fox-dung(LOL)

Lionblaze-Selfish Piece of Fox-dung(LOL)

Hollyleaf-Obsessed Piece of Fox-dung(LOL)

that was fun to say that they are all Fox-Dungs and put a word why. Bossy,Selfish and Obsessed.

Also I hate Lionblaze because he is SO full of himself! he acts better because he can't get hurt! I hate him! With Hollyleaf and brambleclaw!

Jayfeather Rules!

Fox-dungs.*chuckles*

★Silverstar★ said...

LOL that is kind of funny to say. Hollyleaf is fox dung now, but she was my 6th favorite before. Now I don't even know if she's my 10th. It depends on how she acts later. I kind of hope she just died.

Lionblaze is selfish! I don't want him to become leader, he just doesn't seem like he would make a good one.

Jayfeather... I hate his personality, but I can't help but to admire his talents. And he's getting better, so hopefully he will end in my favorites list in the next series.

~~Silverstar

Rainstar said...

No argueing kay!! please keep the peace and i have to agree with delaney on everything though and some on Scarheart!!!

Scarheart said...

Sorry to get on your nerves Rainstar, I just don't want anyone to get their hopes up.

-Scarheart

Delaney said...

Yeah, and soemhow I commentd again, didn't show up. Antways, I don't hate Jayfeather, just i hate his attitude, his ungratefullness, and he's just two nosey. He's ubsessed with a stick. And I know that I agree with Scarheart, Lionblaze iis awsome. And plus, how would he feel SO full off himself, if he thought he needed more training after he was made a warrio. I think he should have a mate, like Icecloud or something. He already killled Tigerstar (figuratively). So, he can't help that he's one of starclan's chosen. I like russetfur, alot too, but that's a DIFFERENT story.

Now, Brambleclaw. It's not like I'm obsessed with him, or something, but he didn't do anything wrong, and niether did Firestar, who, odds are, will toughen up. Brambleclaw could've been trusted, and is mad at Squirrelflight. She has to get her stoies straight, because that was WAY uncool, dude. Brambleclaw was a little funky in the New Prophecy, but Silverstar, i remember you saying one time that Brambleclaw wasn't really tha bad in POT and so, Brambleclaw isn't a peice of fox-dung NONE of the characters ar(except heatheratil) but hey, I'm not going to come to your house, and Shred someone's face. I have other things to worry about, like cookies. (yes! the chocolate chip kind) So, I can't be worrying so much. So every,one, I've been calm this whole time, but You guyz should stop Overreacting. Please, no killing eachother, or hoping characters die. Now, I sugest you stop, or all of us will be sucked into a vortex in another dimension.

★Silverstar★ said...

Um, Rainstar, I wasn't the one arguing. We all can state our opinion nicely, that's what I was doing.

What about Tigerstar? He's fox dung. (LOL that's a funny saying)

I liked Russetfur when she was all friendly to Sasha, but if you'll recall she was one of the cats who sat there and watched Berrykit suffer in the fox trap. I'll never forgive her for that, even if Berrykit did grow up to be a pain in the tail. Well, at least until Honeyfern, but I just hope he will take Poppyfrost as a mate instead and still be nice.

Yes, Brambleclaw wasn't bad at all in the Power of Three. I liked him in that one OK, and if he hadn't acted that way in The New Prophecy I would have liked him just fine. But I can't forgive him because he only started being nice again when Squirrelflight gave in. But think what you wish, I still hate him.

Um, Delaney, look who was yelling in all caps. I did not overreact at all. I'm afraid you did. I'm usually not accusing like this but it really got on my nerves that you would dare to think that I hate warriors just because I'm not fond of Firestar.
Not everyone likes the same cats you do. I have as much a right to say Brambleclaw is fox dung as you do about Heathertail, which you do on a regular basis. I personally like Heathertail some. We all have different opinions, and that's a good thing. I mean, how boring would everything be if we all thought the same thing? LOL.

But I agree, cool down everyone, and remember that it's not a crime to have different opinions of FICTIONAL characters. OK? ;)

~~Silverstar

Delaney said...

Again I WAS BEING SARCASTIC. But anywayz, yeah Tigerstar is, and I really like how Russetfur was nice to sasha. I also wish he would take poppyfrost as a mate, and when we have different ideas, it's niether bad nor good. Heathertail was not a major cahrater! And it wouldn't be boring, different opinions make people wanna came to where you live, and shred your face with a chainsaw. Yep. And you really got on my nerves, too. But, like I said, don't continue to spark people up, like right now, I am close to exploding. But, agrueing spells certain doom, and we'll get sucked into a vortex.

Scarheart said...

Silverstar, your trying to say it NICELY? You keep calling the charactors fox-dund. You couls at least say mouse-dung or mousebrain.

-Scarheart

★Silverstar★ said...

Um, what's the difference again? Fox dung sounds funny like Dreamstar pointed out.

~~Silverstar

★Silverstar★ said...

Listen Delaney, if you and Scarheart get angry at me for stating my opinion about a fictional character and want to yell and threaten, you really need to take a chill pill. I'm sorry but you have really hurt my feelings.

You just called Heathertail fox dung, and I like Heathertail. Am I freaking out? No. She's a fictional cat. Main character or not. Hey, Tigerstar is a main character, so you're saying I should like him, because all of the main characters are cool? I think not. If I call Brambleclaw fox dung, that should be no concern of yours. You've said 'DIE HEATHERTAIL!' many times before in all caps, so I have has as much a right to say that about Brambleclaw.

I did not purposely spark anything, you two took it as a personal offense. Look back over those comments and see who started going at who's throat. Yes, I could have phrased that nicer, but I was not doing anything that you haven't about Heathertail. Not everyone thinks the same way, and that's OK. I could like Tigerstar for all you care, but you don't need to be that way to me.

This is not about warriors anymore, it's about you freaking out at me for having a different opinion. I have feelings too and assuming that I am dung for hating Brambleclaw and that I hate warriors just for not being fond of Firestar really gets me upset.

I'm going now. Good bye.

~~Silverstar

Dreamstar said...

I know. I am not freaking out because you don't like the way Jayfeather acts, personally I like how he acts. It makes it interesting and funny! And everyone says That Jayfeather is obsessed with the stick!

That makes me mad, because NO BODY points fingers at Hollyleaf. She was even more obsessed then jayfeather! Like man! The warrior code! She was COMPLETELY obsessed with that! Jayfeather CARED about the stick because he wanted to know more about the ancient cats. It doesn't mean that he is obsessed. But still...

I hate brambleclaw because he is boring and mean. Like when Squirrelflight was ALWAYS bothering him in the Midnight, he got mad at her. When maybe she was just bugging him because she LIKED him! Has anyone ever thought of that. So of course when Bramblecaw denies her, she turns to Ashfur. A cat who loves her back. But then Brambleclaw gets all jealous because he FINALLY realizes that Squirrelflight likes him, then he goes and breaks them up! That is MEAN! Man...

No one YELL at me for stating my opinions!

Delaney said...

OK SILVERSTAR I WASN'T MAD AT THE LAST COMMENT, YET YOU STILL BRING IT UP! DROP IT! And when I meant main characters, i meant not the EVIL ONES! Plusm, some of the stuff you said you've said already. And don't you relize you've hurt peoples feelings too? And anyways, I wanted to drop it! Oviously you two want to keep it going, so don't yell at me about it! AND I SAID I WAS BEING SARCASTIIC!

★Silverstar★ said...

I was not yelling at all, if you'll look back. Only one place I used all caps because I couldn't make it bold. How could I hurt your feeling by stating my opinion? When you're being sarcastic, make sure you sound it. The reason I brought it up again was because you don't seem to get it. You kept saying I was the one who started it when I wasn't. You are the one who wouldn't drop it and simply allow me to have my own say on things. We don't all have to love Brambleclaw.

Look, you can hate Heathertail and love Brambleclaw and I'll be fine with it even though I disagree. You should be willing to let me think whatever I want about the characters without freaking on me. Do you get my point?

Right with you Dreamstar. Oh, and Jayfeather's stick IS funny, LOL. I think I may like him better in the next series, but I don't know. There are rumors that he'll be nicer, but still. I don't like how he was all rude to Willowshine and won't get over his blindness, but all the same, I still admire his powers as I've said before.

(Sighs) Hollyleaf will always be my favorite of the three. But maybe it's for the better that she's gone. I still her fan but oh well.

~~Silverstar

Delaney said...

Wiat, I was being sarcastioc aboiut who started it, but it'sa not MY feelings your hurting.

★Silverstar★ said...

Huh? What do you mean?

~~Silverstar

Dreamstar said...

Okay. Why are you saying I had to drop it? I was only saying my opinion too.

Delaney said...

Oh, not your opinion, I meant this whole big argument, overreaccting thing. I'VE already stoped.

Rainstar (not logged in) said...

Wow hope a fight doesnt brew

Scarheart said...

Well, I wann't being mean or anything. I'm just saying let's not try 2 fight about this. (That's 1 reason I hate hese, you don't know when they are mad at you.) My whole point on this when I made my first comment, SORRY RAINSTAR, that only 10-5% of this is true or might happen. Once again, if you don't beleive me, just ask. I can prove ALL of these whether they r right or wrong. That's why I made Scarheart's Warriors Blog. It was to tell people whether theories are right or wrong, fun facts, and to tell them things like, FIRESTAR IS GOING TO DIE IN SUNRISE, (are wrong) when it didn't. And because it didn't, now you think he will die in THE FOURTH APPRENTICE! I'm not going to explain if he will or will not, but ask if you wanna know. I don't want people to get their hopes up, then be sad. Hey, I could be 1 of those people who got their hands on a FOURTH APPRENTICE BOOK beore anyone else. Geez, don't beleive every rumor about warriors.

-Scarheart

★Silverstar★ said...

Scarheart - None of us know what theories are right or wrong. You don't, I don't, nobody does but the authors. But I agree that not all of these can be true. Why would one of the the authors just give out all of the big spoilers? It doesn't make sense.

~~Silverstar

Dreamstar said...

I saw these in an Author Chat at WANDS AND WORLDS! Most of these are true! I saw most of these, maybe all, on the latest author chat in june on wands and worlds! Sorry to say but the authors said these things.

Scarheart said...

(To Dreamstar) Okay, if u think it's true, most of it, prove it. Start at #1.

(To Silverstar) I don't know all of these, but I can prove most of these and have enough info. to tell if they will probably be right or wrong. I'M NOT SAYING I KNOW ALL OF THESE 4 SURE, BUT MOST! I have about 5 notebooks FULL of warriors info. . . . .what do you have? I was also at the Erin Chat and have the URL. Most of these ??s were asked, but only a little were answered.

(To Rainstar and Delany) I'm NOT BLAMING anything on u guys, k? Rainstar, all I ask is that try only to put facts. It's ok 2 have theories, but don't get 2 out of hand. I'm getting mad at u.

(To Silverstar and Dreamstar) I kinds of am getting mad at you, Silverstar. Dreamstar, not so much.

-Scarheart

Scarheart said...

RAINSTAR, WAIT! I meant 2 say I'M NOT MAD AT U! Ooops, sorry! :D

-Scarheart

Dreamstar said...

QUESTIONS:

Minou(Q): The prophecy refers to the three as being "kin of [Firestar's] kin", but Dovekit and Ivykit are technically kin of his kin of his kin. How do you explain this?
VickyHolmes(A): “Kin” means “relative”, not just the closest generation. So your grandparents are your kin, your great-grandparents, your cousin’s children, their grandchildren – if anyone is linked to you by blood, they are your kin. Technically, the prophecy could have just said “your kin”, but that didn’t have the nice ring that “kin of your kin” does!---True. I saw this one there.

Sandcloud(Q): Did you always mean to make Hollyleaf um... go out like she did? and thank you for all you did at the Naperville tour!
VickyHolmes(A): I’ll be honest (gasp! Actually, I’m always honest, I just sometimes hide a bit of the truth): in The Sight, Hollyleaf was absolutely and totally one of the Three in the Prophecy. I always wanted to send her into a place where she would end up doing something dreadful, but I thought this would come about because she misused her extraordinary powers. But by Book Three, I just couldn’t think what Hollyleaf’s power was. Jay and Lion had walked straight into their roles from the moment they appeared in my head, but Holly seemed to reject everything I offered her, from foreseeing the future to reading minds (unlike Jay, who senses emotions but can only read memories). Nothing seemed to fit – and I realized, literally overnight, that she was never meant to have a power. She wasn’t one of the Three, and the knowledge of this would help to crush her, along with all the other doom I had lined up for her. I LOVE it when characters find their own destinies like that!---True. I saw this one there.

Quailfeather(Q): In Sunrise when Leafpool stepped down from being a Medicine Cat, did she step down to a Warriors status, or was she banished?
VickyHolmes(A): You’ll find out in Omen of the Stars Book One! She’s still on the cast list, if that’s any consolation.---True. I saw this one there.

Rainfall(Q): Why did you choose to kill Honeyfern?
VickyHolmes(A): You’re not going to be very pleased with me, I’m afraid. I needed a cat to be killed by a snake in order to have a reason to have deathberries in the hollow, so that Hollyleaf could threaten to kill Leafpool with them later on. I worked back from that scenario, thinking, hmmm, what would be an excuse for Leafpool to have deathberries in her stores when she is so strict about not having them in the camp? How else might she use deathberries? How about laying a trap for something that deserved to be killed? Like…a nasty ol’ snake that bit a helpless innocent cat? Leafpool or another cat might come up with the idea of stuffing a mouse with deathberries to lay a deadly bait for the snake. Now, who can I kill with a snake? Hmmmm… Poor Honeyfern. ***.---True. I saw this one there.


Phantomwing(Q): While all of us might wonder about Leafpool, Hollyleaf and Squirrelflight, I wonder about this: what will happen to Crowfeather? While he may have SEEMED to be over Leafpool, we all know that this is not the case, and that he only acted like he did to save face at the Gathering. His Clanmates might get distrustful of him again, knowing that he has two living sons in ThunderClan.
VickyHolmes(A): You are SO RIGHT! Crowfeather is heaving with all kinds of conflicting emotions right now, but as always, it’s hard to know what he’s thinking underneath his gruff, unfriendly exterior. Only Leafpool and Feathertail were able to see beyond that to the sensitive, loving chap underneath (I’m pretty sure Nightcloud has no idea of her mate’s true character). The revelations at the end of Power of Three will echo far into Omen of the Stars, and Crowfeather’s adventures definitely aren’t over. So many good stories to come!---True. I saw this one there.

Dreamstar said...

Flametail von Karma(Q): Do Dove’s Wing and Dovekit have any correlation? Also, Half Moon has “strong haunches”, and her father bears an eerie resemblance to Cloudstar. Is this just a coincidence? Not to mention that Whispering Breeze “doesn’t mind getting her paws wet”. Is this implying something about RiverClan, perhaps…?
VickyHolmes(A): Well spotted! I **** lots of clues about the future Clans in the community of ancient cats - so yes, some cats resemble cats we meet later on, some have characteristics that will feature in the modern Clans like not minding water. But Dove's Wing and Dovekit are not directly connected.---True. I saw this one there.


Firefawn(Q): why did you kill Hollyleaf?
VickyHolmes(A): Did I? Where does it say that?---True. I saw this one there.


Scorchtail(Q): Were Jayfeather and Hollyleaf named after their real parents? But how would Firestar know to name Hollyleaf after her mother?
VickyHolmes(A): Leafpool gave Jayfeather his name as a medicine cat, so yes, she chose it because of Crowfeather. I imagine the parents of a new warrior have some say in their new name, so Squirrelflight would have suggested –leaf to Firestar for Hollypaw. Firestar would have seen this as a tribute to Squirrelflight’s beloved sister, little realizing that it was actually a tribute to Hollyleaf’s real mother!---True. I saw this one there.



Lakestorm Wright(Q): If Jayfeather went into the tunnels, and came out in Jay's Wing's time, where did Jay's Wing go? I mean, he had to go somewhere when he went into the tunnels, right?
VickyHolmes(A): Oh no, I was hoping no one was going to ask me about this! Cherith asked me exactly the same thing when she was writing Long Shadows, and I gave her a really convincing answer, but the details seem to have got lost in the fog of my mind. I think I meant that Jayfeather actually became Jay’s Wing – not a reincarnation, not a temporary possession of his body – and by making the decision to go back to ThunderClan, Jay’s Wing had to leave his own Ancient Clanmates to follow a path that he had set for them. Does that make sense? Probably not.---Don't know.



Cometstorm(Q): What exactly will Omen of the Stars be about? I know that one of Whitewing's kits is the three, but can't you just give us a little teaser PLEASE??? Like what the "omen" is?
VickyHolmes(A): Dovekit is the "fourth" apprentice, and the true third cat mentioned in the prophecy. As you can imagine, her sister Ivykit is none too pleased about her littermate's special destiny... And that's enough revelations!---True. I saw this one there.

Rainripple(Q): Is Dovekit the fourth apprentice?
VickyHolmes(A): Yup!---True. I saw this one there.


Cloudy Havoqk(Q): Since Cinderpelt was in love with Firestar, will Cinderheart have a crush on him?
VickyHolmes(A): Tee hee, I hadn't thought of that! I think she just might... Thanks for the idea!---Don't know


Flametail von Karma(Q): Can you tell us anything about who will become leader after Firestar? We know it won’t be Brambleclaw, and will be unexpected. Will it be a relatively new character? (New meaning from Power of Three onward here.)
VickyHolmes(A): No I cannot tell you anything about who becomes leader after Firestar. Because I am EVIL.---True. I saw this one there.

Ice(Q): Is Leapordstar(sp) going to die any time soon, I would love to see a Mistystar.
VickyHolmes(A): Actually, I don't think I'm giving too much away to reveal that Leopardstar has just died in Omen of the Stars Book Two! Mistystar is now the leader of RiverClan!---True. I saw this one there.

Dreamstar said...

Cloudy Havoqk(Q): Do you ever write stories out of order? Like the last chapter first? Or do you always start with the first chapter?
VickyHolmes(A): Oh yes. The scene featuring Ashfur, Squirrelflight, Jay, Lion and Holly (and some fire and the cliff) came into my head before I even started thinking about The Sight. So the whole series was working up to that moment! But when it comes to planning an actual book, I make myself begin at the beginning, go right to the end, and stop.---True. I saw this one there.

Morningleaf(Q): Does Heathertail still like Lionblaze? Or are her and Breezepelt really in love?
VickyHolmes(A): Poor Heathertail, I suspect part of her heart still belongs to Lionblaze even though she knows it is an Impossible Love (yay, one of my favourite things!). No way are she and Breezepelt in love! Although their relationship is more complicated than "just friends".---Don't know.


Heartwing(Q): Why did you just have Leafpool retire? I love her but I was expecting Holly to kill her.
VickyHolmes(A): How could she stay as a medicine cat, when she has broken the code so dramatically? And LIED about her children? Leafpool has only herself to blame, sigh.---Don't know.


Minou(Q): Will where Brightspirit comes from be explained? Jayfeather didn't recognize them from StarClan.
VickyHolmes(A): Brightspirit came from long, long ago in the history of Clans - it's quite likely that we'll meet her later on in Omen, as we learn more about the formation of the early Clans.---Don't know.

Storme(Q): Was it really just pride that stopped Leopardstar from breaking her agreement with Tigerstar(when he was about to kill the half-Clans), or was there another factor--something she would never admit out loud--like fear?
VickyHolmes(A): Good question! Most definitely, Leopardstar was afraid of Tigerstar - but also in love with him, poor thing.---True. I saw this one there.


Wildflower(Q): Why do you think the Clans are seeming to fall apart now, when they have always been so solid before? Much of it seems to be blamed on poor Firestar by the other Clans because of the leaders turning against ThunderClan. Or is all this because of teh prophecy?
VickyHolmes(A): The Clans are falling apart because they are subject to many, many new pressures - not just moving home, but incoming influences like Sol. The Prophecy hasn't caused the trouble, but it anticipated it, hence the promise of three super-powered cats to bring the Clans back to their original strength.---Don't know.

Dreamstar said...

FireWolf787(Q): Who is Mistystar's deputy?
VickyHolmes(A): Reedwhisker, one of the cats that Firestar and Graystripe rescued during a flood. Reedpaw is Misty's Son? Oh gosh, you're right!---True. I saw this one there.

Spottedshadow(Q): Will Ivykit be evil?
VickyHolmes(A): She'll be pretty miffed that her sister is getting all the attention, that's for sure!---True. I saw this one there.

FrostfootDreamleaf (Q): Are Breezepelt and Heathertail mates?
VickyHolmes(A): Nope.---True. I saw this one there.


Minou (Q) (to All, but especially Vicky): In regard to Hollyleaf, do you consider her the evil one? Was she really evil, or just angry and confused? Also, if she isn't the "Evil One", is she alive and going to come back as evil or is she dead and one of the others will become evil? (btw Hollyleaf looks adorable on the cover of Sunrise =D)
VickyHolmes(A): I’ve said before that none of my cats are truly evil – not even Scourge or Tigerstar, although it might take a few books to reveal the parts of their history that sent them in a particular direction. Hint: see Code of the Clans for a big clue about Tigerstar’s crazed hatred of kittypets! As for Hollyleaf, she was definitely angry and confused. She felt that she had been backed into a course of action that, however repulsive to her, was the only way she could save her Clanmates from knowing that the warrior code had been trampled in the dust. Sadly, the more she learned, the more she realized that there was no way to save them from this terrible knowledge. I’m not going to give away anything about what, if anything, lies in Hollyleaf’s future beyond Sunrise…---True. I saw this one there.


Lightstreaqk (Q): Vicky: (I wrote you a letter a few weeqks ago ) Hollyleaf was either crushed by the caves when they actually caved in, or while lost in the tunnels, right? Would her spirit wander the tunnels forever, liqke Fallen Leaves, or will it go somewhere else? In the summary for Sunrise, it said someone would be 'lost forever' Is that what it meant?
VickyHolmes(A): Not sure I can reply to this without giving too much away! But yes, “lost forever” referred to Hollyleaf as she appeared to her Clanmates at that time. Hint, hint.---Don't know

Dreamstar said...

Spottedshadow (Q): To Vicky: I'm a bit confused about the fourth apprentice. If either Ivykit or Dovekit is the fourth apprentice (I have a suspicion as to which kit it is, from the book covers, but I won't say anything), who are the other three? I'd assume they were Lionblaze, Hollyleaf, and Jayfeather, but if Hollyleaf isn't really included anymore... and also, they aren't apprentices anymore. And, is the fourth apprentice the third cat mentioned in the phrophecy? Because if the third cat in the prophecy is the third apprentice, the fourth apprentice could be a problem... maybe even evil. It seems like finding out your sibling was included in a prophecy and you were just normal might be hard to take...
VickyHolmes(A): SPOILER ALERT FOR SUNRISE: Ack, too many numbers in your question! I think it’s generally known now that Dovekit is the cat referred to as The Fourth Apprentice. The other three are Jay, Lion and Holly, because all four have been “apprentices” to the Prophecy. However, Holly was never part of the prophecy, which referred all along to Jay, Lion and Dove. Gasp! So four apprentices, but only ever three cats who were part of the prophecy. And you’re right, learning that your littermate was part of a super-powerful prophecy while you’re not could send any cat down the path of evil…---True. I saw this one there.


Brambleflower (Q): How is Breezepelt dealing with the news that his father had a mate from a different Clan and had three kits with her?
VickyHolmes(A): One word: BADLY.---Don't know, but probably true! LOL!

Scarletpetal (Q): What happened between Daisy and Spiderleg? I mean it was REALLY sudden, like just popped up O_o
VickyHolmes(A): Yup, it was kind of a one-night affair, and Spiderleg was pretty aghast when Daisy announced that she was expecting his kits. I wanted to reflect the fact that in real life, cats don’t mate for life, and pairs wouldn’t raise their kits together in a cosy little family. Obviously longer-term relationships work better in the series, but I thought it wouldn’t do any harm to let some realism creep in. Also, I saw great story potential in Spiderleg being a reluctant father - usually a tom is super-proud of his kits and very affectionate toward his mate, but Spiderleg doesn’t want anything to do with parental duties! This leads to the strength of Daisy’s character coming out, as she forces him to confront his responsibilities, while being a great single mom. There’s a cat for all of us!---Don't know.


Okay. So more then half of those were true. probably almost all were, but I didn't want to look through the WHOLE Author Chat, AGAIN!

Delaney said...

Man, that was long and unnecessary, wow, Erin Hunter does give out a lot of fausle info

★Silverstar★ said...

Scarheart - Um, why are you getting mad at me? I'm just saying that I doubt that all of those theories listed are right, and I doubt that you can prove all of them right or wrong. I was responding to your first comment's direct quote of:

I can prove ALL of these whether they r right or wrong.

But gee, no need to get mad at me. I'm agreeing with you that they not all of them are true. And yes, I am just as crazy about Warrior theories as you are, and just because you keep notebooks doesn't make you any better. FYI, I happen to keep computer documents of theories, thank you very much. See, you don't know how much a research, do you?

I apologize if I'm sounding rough, but what happened to us all being able to debate peacefully on Sorrelpaw's Blog? We used to be able to share theories and thoughts about characters without anyone getting hurt feelings. What changed here?

~~Silverstar

Rainstar said...

Okay you know i put this stuff on here for other warrior fans to see im not saying that they are true Scarheart i take some of the things you say offensivly its not nice. Its therories!!! Jesus lord will you all stop arguing im getting sick of it!!! and dont say bad things about my blog i post what i fnd if its true or not and geuss what FIRESTAR IS GONNA DIE IN OMEN OF THE STARS FIRST OR SECOND BOOK!!!

Rainstar said...

i dont know what changed but sorrelpaw quit posting and the only other info blogs ive seen are my own and Scarhearts

★Silverstar★ said...

I agree, I'm tired of people getting all worked up over little things like this. Delaney got mad at me for having a different opinion about Brambleclaw (at least that's cleared up now) and Scarheart is currently mad at me for... well, I don't honestly know why she's mad. I can't see one reason, she just said she was mad at me and I have no clue why.

~~Silverstar

Scarheart said...

Jeez, I never said I didn't like your blog, Rainstar. I luv it! Infact if I'm not mad at anybody it's u and Delany. My feelings r getting hurt now. Remember, I'm only 11! You guys r what, 12, 13 or older, right? Also, I'm just saying MY OPOINION. Also, Silverstar, if you don't beleive that I can prove MOST OF THEM, ask me. But please, no offense Dreamsar, one at a time. I can't take all of that information at once! ;) I have nothing against any of you. I like u all, infact I wish we could meet in real life.

-Scarheart

★Silverstar★ said...

Um, I wasn't ASSUMING you were mad, you SAID you were mad at me. Direct quote here:

"I kinds of am getting mad at you, Silverstar. Dreamstar, not so much."

So yeah, I'm going to defend myself, wouldn't you? I'm not making this up, go up before Dreamstar's posts and see exactly what I was commenting about.

~~Silverstar

Delaney said...

Let's to the time warp again! You see what you did?.......:) The time is aprocing, it makes u go insa-a-a-a-ane! Let, DO THE TIME WARP AGAIN! The votox has approched, were Fay ray and king kong, got INTO A CELLULIOD JAM! We've doomed,.... ourselves... and only fate, can tell, what would happen! (evil cackle)

(ps this is a song)

Rainstar said...

im 12 not that much older than you we are all around the same age. but that doesnt matter i want everyone to stop arguing and just think about some ones opion. I like brambleclaw and hate Heathertail. So what im not making a big deal about it to people who like heathertail and hate brambleclaw. It doesnt matter everyone has an opinion and a say in everthing so everyone take a chill pill and respect everyone elses opinions. Sorrelpaw isnt posting nothing and i post the latest stuff i can find true or not its therories and really no one knows for sure if any of it is true. Who knows. I dont what any crud from anyone just because i post stuff that may be false. I thought this was an author chat so i posted it. Now from now on i want every to get along or else i dont care how old anyone here is even if they are older than me :) Good day to everyone PS THIS IS DIRECTED TOWARDS ANYONE NO HARD FEELINGS :D

Scarheart said...

You said these were ALL FACTS, not theories. (Facts:.....) I have now read through them all. At first, I only skimmed it, but at first I also said that less than half were true. I now change that 2 SOME of these r wrong. (About 20% wrong.) But still I CAN PROVE ALMOST EVERY 1! Probably all, but that would take a LONG time. I'm done with this. (Done with this post, not your blog, Rainstar.) There is now 60 comments made by only 5 people. Ridiculas! (I wish my warriors blog was this popular.)

Rainstar, you may be 12, but probably almost 13. I turned 11, in 5th grade, this year, on August 31. Delany is 13, and Silverstar and Dreamstar r probably 13 too. (Correct me if I'm wrong!)

-Scarheart

Rainstar said...

january is my birthday

Rainstar said...

i copied and pasted it i myself never said they were facts!!!

Scarheart said...

FACTS:
-Hollyleaf is most likely alive
-Hollyleaf HAD powers until Outcast, when she became the non-power of three
-Leafpool is no longer a medicine cat
-Leafpool is still residing in ThunderClan
-Pinestar is NOT Firestar's father
-There is no Dove's Wing--Dovekit connection -***-
-Lionblaze will have a mate
-Heathertail is still in love with Lionblaze
-Breezepelt and Heathertail will NOT be mates
-Poppyfrost will have a mate and kits in the first book.
-Foxpaw's warrior name is Foxleap
-Icepaw's warrior name is Icecloud
-Cinderpelt was in love with Firestar; Cinderheart has a vague crush on him.
-Brightheart will have an apprentice
-Brambleclaw will NOT succeed Firestar as leader of ThunderClan
-Firestar will lose most of his remaining lives
-DOVEKIT is the fourth apprentice
-Ivykit is jealous of her sister, which MAY drive her to insanity/Hollyleaf/Tigerclaw
-Tigerpaw's warrior name is Tigerheart
-Barkface is dead
-OOTS will have FOUR veiwpoints: Jay, Lion, Dove, and Ivy
-Leopardstar will die in book two
-Mistyfoot will become Mistystar
-Reedwhisker is her deputy
-Reedwhisker is Mistystar's son
-Dawn, Flame, and Tigerpaw will play an important part with Tigerstar
-Purdy will stay in ThunderClan
-Brambleclaw and Squirrelflight will not have kits
-The lake will drain because of beavers building a dam upstream
-The scene with Ashfur, Squirrelflight, and the Three was written before Power of Three
-Goldenflower died of old age in her sleep between Sunset and the Sight
-Stormfur and Brook have kits
-Leopardstar was in love with Tigerstar

And I just copied and pasted that.

-Scarheart

Scarheart said...

-Hollyleaf is most likely alive
1. On this 1, it is more of a teory, but since you said MOST LIKELY, it is still a fact.

-Hollyleaf HAD powers until Outcast, when she became the non-power of three
1. She never had powers. If you think she did, what were her power(s)?

-Leafpool is no longer a medicine cat
1. Leafpool SAID she was resigning, but Vicky said u would have to wait 4 the FOURTH APPRENTICE. That means she has not given any info about Leafpool in the books. Otherwise she would have said yes, she is no longer medicine cat.

-Brambleclaw will NOT succeed Firestar as leader of ThunderClan
1. Once again, WHERE did this come from. Vicky never said this.

-Reedwhisker is Mistystar's son
1. Nothing wrong with this, but her kits r REEDWHISKER, RIPPLETAIL, DAWNFLOWER, AND GRAYMIST

-Brambleclaw and Squirrelflight will not have kits
1. It said they will PROBABLY will not. They still could.

There I have justified my thinking. All I wanted to do. Tell you the ones that are wrong.

-Scarheart

Rainstar said...

and i never said any of them were right i said i found it I didnt type it someone else did!!!

Scarheart said...

Well, you should be more careful. Whoever typed those, needs to get focused. Cool awards!

-Scarheart

Rainstar said...

oh thanks yeah this was on the warrior chat thing on the website and i was searching for spoilers and it came up so i copied it and posted it. oh well ill keep my eyes peeled for more stuff about this.

Anonymous said...

Great Starclan!!! this is my top 10 list 10.Thornclaw, 9.Tawnypelt, 8.Crowfeather, 7.Reedwhisker, 6.Cinderheart, 5.Icecloud, 4.Dustpelt, 3.Cloudtail, 2.Heathertail, 1.Brakenfur.My god I hate everyone else!!!!

★Silverstar★ said...

EVERYONE? What about Sorreltail? Mistyfoot? Whitestorm? Stormfur? Barley?

My favorites are:

1: Sandstorm
2: Cinderpelt/Cinderheart
3: Stormfur
4: Mistyfoot
5: Tallstar
6: Ravenpaw
7: Spottedleaf
8: Whitestorm
9: Mousewhisker
10: Hollyleaf

~~Silverstar

Dreamstar said...

I am 12. I am in 7th grade!

★Silverstar★ said...

Cool, I am 13 and in 8th grade.

~~Silverstar

Rainstar (notlogged in) said...

im 12 in 7th

My favs are everyone except firestar onestar i absolutely love Tigerstar and Hawkfrost! know why? (they tried to kill firestar oh and i love scorge too for the same reason.

★Silverstar★ said...

*Cough* Why on earth do you like all the evil cats? My least favorites are:

1: Hawkfrost
2: Leopardstar
3: Tigerstar
4: Stoneteller
5: Brambleclaw
6: Blackstar
7: Onestar
8: Darkstripe
9: Scourge

~~Silverstar

★Silverstar★ said...

Oh I missed 10 sorry. That would be either Bone or Brokentail.

~~Silverstar

Rainstar said...

because they trird to kill firestar

Anonymous said...

I thought you said that you LIKED Firestar and Onestar. And what about all of the other cats they killed?

~~Silverstar (Not logged in)

Scarheart said...

I'm 11 in 5th grade.

-Scarheart

Buzz Girl said...

My favs r...
1. Leafpool
2. Sandstorm
3. Firestar
4. Sorreltail
5. Brackenfur
6. Squirrelflight
7. Cinderheart/Cinderpelt
8. Crowfeather
9. Brook
10. Feathertail
And Im 14, a freshman in high school. I really don't kno why you guys are telling everyone your ages.
-Buzz Girl

Rainstar (notlogged in said...

i hate onestar and firestar

Sorry im never logged in

Firefern said...

Hi my favs are
1. Bluestar
2. Honeyfern
3. Leafpool
4. Firestar
5. Sorreltail
6. Brackenfur
7. Squirreltail
8. Sandstorm
9. Cinderpelt/Heart
10. Brambleclaw

also im actually 12 and im in 8th grade

Rainstar said...

go brambleclaw!!!

Cinderstar said...

Just found this blog randomly!

my fave cats..

1.Jayfeather(DUH!)
2.Leafpool
3.crowfeather(he is misunderstood but i love him!)
4.Firestar(awsomest cat ever)
5.Cinderpelt/Cinderheart(prefer cinderPELT)
6.Brambleclaw (not good or bad just awsome!)
7.Squirrelflight (how can u not like her?)
8.Ravenpaw (miss him soo much)
9.Sandstorm (a fighter)
10.Princess (love the name!and she is brave!)

13 and 1/3 Grade 8

i also dnt get why everyone's posting their age?
but it helps me alot so i now know the normal age group for ppl who have warrior blogs!
and i know wht i can say
(lol before i was worried to say the smallest thing in case there were some 5th graders here!)

My blog

Vineclan
Where the prey runs as thick as the vines that surround it.
www.cinderstar-vineclan.blogspot.com

Anonymous said...

You said that the forest needs 3 super powered cats to bring the clans up to strength. wouldn't that just mean thunderclan will be the only strong clan. I see 2 possible solutions 1) There are special cats in other clan or Lionblaze or dovekit (not jaypaw he's thunderclans only medicine cat) Go to a different clan?

Anonymous said...

Wasn't Reedwhisker Mistyfoot's apprentice? Aren't parents not supposed to mentor their kits?

Anonymous said...

hollyleaf is now dead and with fallen leaves? thats wat i believe. anyways, to tell you the truth I was expecting hollyleaf 2 become the leader of thunderclan after firestar dies but now that she died it was like a surprise. well, can yuh give away any spoilers of the forth apperantece book becuz im a bit confused.

Anonymous said...

will jayfeather have an apperantce?

Anonymous said...

Man, you guys are way far ahead of me in the Warriors books! I'm only on book 3 series 1! Man, how do you read that quick!? I mean you read at the speed of lightining I guess! lol. Man,your talking about charcters that I have NO IDEA who they are! Please tell me the trick to reading those huge books that quick! Also, AWESOME BLOG! I love the background. It's cool. I just read all these comments, and man, are they spoilers or what! And also, i agree with Silverstar and Dreamstar. Not to make anyone freak out, but i just hope you guys can work things out. I also agree with Rainstar. Another thing was that Scourge sounds like a cool charcter. Awesome blog Rainstar, and i hope you all work out your fight thingy. (P.S. lol Jayfeather and the stick sounds hilarious! lol) =)

Rainstar said...

Thank you ive been reading the books since last year and i read pretty quick the more into the book you are the faster you read it. And thank you. Yes Jayfeather and his stick are quite funny!

Anonymous said...

dbijodkngbobjvgxhuxx, http://yahooscanner.net yahoo Scanner, mCPBAXv.

Anonymous said...

I'm new here @ sparkletailsblog.blogspot.com and wanna say hi to all the guys/gals of this board!

Anonymous said...

nD4M6g http://ugg-stiefel.webspawner.com bI5V4i [url=http://ugg-stiefel.webspawner.com]ugg stiefel[/url] yJ8X5r ugg boots g√ľnstig uW5A1f
oT9J2z http://goedkopebestellen.jouwweb.nl xY0H9n [url=http://goedkopebestellen.jouwweb.nl]uggs outlet[/url] dN6E5c goedkope uggs bestellen pM9S2d
dE1J2x http://www.bootssincanada.info tE5W0r [url=http://www.bootssincanada.info]uggs canada[/url] rD0V1w ugg canada kR3Z2t
kS9W5d http://botasuggss.1minutesite.es cA6N4l [url=http://botasuggss.1minutesite.es]botas ugg baratas[/url] yI7G0q ugg qW1H2i
iT0I9g http://stivalishop.oneminutesite.it zI0O9x [url=http://stivalishop.oneminutesite.it]ugg italia[/url] eS4D5r ugg gS7U1j
jQ6Z2e http://bootskopenonline.jouwweb.nl kB9O5o [url=http://bootskopenonline.jouwweb.nl]uggs uitverkoop[/url] fF3F9c uggs online lS5J7l

Anonymous said...

[URL=http://pharmacypills.atspace.co.uk/dostinex/dostinex-manufacturer.html]dostinex manufacturer[/URL]

Anonymous said...

Did you [url=http://www.onlinecasinos.gd]roulette[/url] almost that you can dally with Revolving Peer royalty be born without wait from your mobile? We possess a peerlessness transportable casino elbow seeking iPhone, iPad, Android, Blackberry, Windows 7 and Smartphone users. Take safe keeping of your gaming with you and be a protect [url=http://www.avi.vg]dildo[/url] wherever you go.

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.microgiving.com/profile/ribavirin]virazole buy
[/url] purchase rebetol online
ribavirin online
order ribavirin

Anonymous said...

sA0G0q http://isabelmarantss.1minutesite.es/ eW6H1c [url=http://isabelmarantss.1minutesite.es/]isabel marant[/url] rB5Z5n isabel marant sneakers iB8S2o
qG7F4u http://headphoneshop.webs.com dG5D8w [url=http://headphoneshop.webs.com]monster headphones[/url] vD9B2y dr dre headphones yG4N2j
yI4N0f http://ussneaker.webs.com lO2U2z [url=http://ussneaker.webs.com]isabel marant[/url] nN7I3w isabel marant wO9C7m
rX3T4x http://onlinesneakers.webnode.fr wB6O0q [url=http://onlinesneakers.webnode.fr ]isabel marant[/url] gC6K7h isabel marant aI6L2d
zZ5D8p http://sneakershopes.webnode.es dP0A2e [url=http://sneakershopes.webnode.es]isabel marant[/url] eP9T8d isabel marant sneakers zH3R2r
uP2H0b http://dphonesbeatsbydre.com eW6J0p [url=http://dphonesbeatsbydre.com]beats dr dre[/url] uD3K0n cheap beats by dre bP5S1i